I'd been a happy user of Asus video cards (and other Asus products) for several years. They offer a 3 year warranty, which is about right. But because of the buzz on this forum about the lifetime warranty EVGA offers, when I made the jump to a 8800 GTX last April, I got the EVGA.
I generally register the products I get, especially the expensive ones, if I can do it online. I tried with EVGA and got stuck on the "email verification" which never came back. So I spaced on it.
Now, a mere 7 months after getting the EVGA card, it failed. So I went to the EVGA web site to get an RMA, and I discovered that I needed to register within 30 days for the lifetime warranty to be valid. Where the hell did it say that? On the web site if you look for it, no doubt, but I never remember seeing anything like this on the box.
So now I have a failed card, with only a few months remaining on the 1 year warranty they offer if you miss your 30 day registration window. 1 year.
Think the Asus 3 year real warranty is a better deal. Especially since I've never had an Asus video card fail.
So the warning is: better rethink the "lifetime warranty" EVGA touts. It's sort of a bait and switch because it turns out to be really hard to actually register it. The process gets stuck, emails (which it says to send if you don't get the confirmation email) aren't answered, and it takes days from card failure to getting an RMA so you can send it in.
The Asus (and I expect most others) turns out to be a better, more realistic, less dishonest warranty.
Edit starts here -------------------------------------------------------------
This has been resolved in my favor by Joe Darwin from EVGA. I retract the negative speculation, as it now appears to me that EVGA is trying to offer a better deal, especially to enthusiasts, and while there may be some rough spots in the process, they are trying to get it right
A full retraction has been posted at the current end of this thread, here:
http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1031936766&postcount=104
I generally register the products I get, especially the expensive ones, if I can do it online. I tried with EVGA and got stuck on the "email verification" which never came back. So I spaced on it.
Now, a mere 7 months after getting the EVGA card, it failed. So I went to the EVGA web site to get an RMA, and I discovered that I needed to register within 30 days for the lifetime warranty to be valid. Where the hell did it say that? On the web site if you look for it, no doubt, but I never remember seeing anything like this on the box.
So now I have a failed card, with only a few months remaining on the 1 year warranty they offer if you miss your 30 day registration window. 1 year.
Think the Asus 3 year real warranty is a better deal. Especially since I've never had an Asus video card fail.
So the warning is: better rethink the "lifetime warranty" EVGA touts. It's sort of a bait and switch because it turns out to be really hard to actually register it. The process gets stuck, emails (which it says to send if you don't get the confirmation email) aren't answered, and it takes days from card failure to getting an RMA so you can send it in.
The Asus (and I expect most others) turns out to be a better, more realistic, less dishonest warranty.
Edit starts here -------------------------------------------------------------
This has been resolved in my favor by Joe Darwin from EVGA. I retract the negative speculation, as it now appears to me that EVGA is trying to offer a better deal, especially to enthusiasts, and while there may be some rough spots in the process, they are trying to get it right
A full retraction has been posted at the current end of this thread, here:
http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1031936766&postcount=104