[H]ard|Forum

Go Back   [H]ard|Forum > [H]ard|Ware > Overclocking & Cooling

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
  #1  
Old 01-08-2007, 12:21 PM
Kyle_Bennett HardOCP Editor-in-Chief, 12.7 Years
 
Kyle_Bennett is online now
CoolIT Freezone Chilled Liquid CPU Cooler

CoolIT Freezone Chilled Liquid CPU Cooler - Is CoolIT’s hybrid, TEC chilled, water cooler up to the task of cooling your CPU? We find out how water cooling with no radiator works. Turns out to be user-friendly as well.

Quote:
Until I saw it for myself, I didn’t truly believe a unit the size of a power supply could best a triple 120mm radiator based watercooling setup. Not only did it beat every system we have tested so far, the Freezone maintained moderate noise levels while doing so. To top it all off, this thing had more in it! I left the potentiometer on the control board in the stock position for all of my testing.
  #2  
Old 01-08-2007, 12:28 PM
newls1 2[H]4U, 6.4 Years
 
newls1 is offline
Im really pondering the idea of buying this instead of a triple 120mm rad setup.... Anyone disagree? Could this keep load temps below 50c for a E6600 with 1.5+Vcore?
__________________
<<<<<NO PC>>>>>
2002 Tahoe / 7000watts going to 4 18" HDC3's / DC Power Dual 300Amp ALTS / 3 DEKA Intimidator G31 batts / MLA 15.4v module / 100+FT of 0/1ot power/ground cables / 25CUFT box @ 36Hz 442SQIN port/ etc...... LOUD!
  #3  
Old 01-08-2007, 01:11 PM
BlueCreek n00bie, 3.1 Years
 
BlueCreek is offline
Re: newls1 - I've read at least half a dozen reviews on this product in the past couple days and the answer is an unequivacable YES, so long as you don't run it on low power (in which case it can't even outperform an aircooler.) Move it up to mid-max however and this system really blows everything away (at least, that is what I have read.)

There is also their new Eliminator, which is even easier to install, has greater case compatibility, runs cpu load within a couple degrees of the Freezone, and at only half the cost.

Seems the biggest issue is you need to run the fan at mid-max speed to reap the benefits, which puts you acoustically back in the air cooling range. Might be able to swap out the fan though for a quieter one like a pabst or noctua, but I'd wait a month to make sure it is all still working great before voiding your warranty.

Still, definately worth strong consideration for anyone who does not want/need to cool their graphics cards as well as their CPU. Otherwise you'd be spending money on two totally seperate systems and trying to find space for it all.

I must admit, I was sold on a Swiftech system just a couple days ago, but am seriously considering their Eliminator. My other option is just waiting a few more months to OC my system because CoolIT is supposed to come out with another unit more directly suitable for the quad core.
  #4  
Old 01-08-2007, 01:23 PM
BillParrish Moderator, 3.5 Years
 
BillParrish is offline
Quote:
Until I saw it for myself, I didn’t truly believe a unit the size of a power supply could best a triple 120mm radiator based watercooling setup. Not only did it beat every system we have tested so far, the Freezone maintained moderate noise levels while doing so. To top it all off, this thing had more in it! I left the potentiometer on the control board in the stock position for all of my testing.
Wow , but its about time someone got it (easy bolt on that doesnt suck) right.

Bet I could plumb a GPU block into that loop in about 3 minutes

Really want to see the cheaper unit reviewed - come on Freezone you cant beat this kind of advertising for the cost of a demo unit.
__________________
Q6600 9x375 3.37GHz 1.382V (it wlll go faster)
Gigabye P965-DQ6 ver 1.0 Heatpipe mods + fans
G.Skill 2x2GB 4:3 1000MHz 5-5-5-12 2.1V tRD=8
EVGA 8800GT SC
4x Hitachi 3.0Gb/s deathstars 160GB in RAID 5, 1x Hitachi 240GB standalone.
Corsair VX-550
Tt Bigwater 745 water cooling + Swiftech GPU block
Thermal margin (delta to Tjmax) 61/60/64/63C @ idle, 35/35/39/40C @ load - @ 25C ambient, Orthos small FFT.
  #5  
Old 01-08-2007, 02:09 PM
phide [H]ardForum Junkie, 5.7 Years
 
phide is offline
While I appreciate the review, I think it may be time for Justin to start using die simulators rather than a typical CPU. Although they may not accurately represent a modern CPU, they allow for much more stable (and more accurate) measurements than a CPU's on-board diodes. The accuracy and relative accuracy of both Intel and AMD user-readable diodes is questionable.

Well, just a thought, anyway.
__________________
GENERAL MAYHEM POSTER OF THE YEAR 2009 RUNNER-UP
"Recovering a deleted file from recycle bin: 50 dollars; Installing a cpu 100 dollars; Finding pedo pictures on the computer: princess." -TheBuzzer
  #6  
Old 01-08-2007, 02:48 PM
vinylkid n00bie, 3.5 Years
 
vinylkid is offline
I've been running a Freezone for the better part of 9 months now. While it does a great job of keeping temperatures down at stock voltages (and relatively modest overclocks ... say, an Opteron 170 @ 1.55v, or a E6400 @ 1.55v), the unit can get noisy when you start pushing your overclocks. The heat dissipation capabilities of the pelts and their heatsink really become apparent on high overclocks. Also, after 9 months of operation I do notice that a wee bit of air has gotten into the loop, without a reservoir or fillport you can't do anything about this.

Quote:
Originally Posted by newls1 View Post
Im really pondering the idea of buying this instead of a triple 120mm rad setup.... Anyone disagree? Could this keep load temps below 50c for a E6600 with 1.5+Vcore?
The typical temperature delta on my C2D E6400 @ 1.55v is 34c idle, 62c load on the highest cooling setting (ambient room temperature is around 22c). That's a pretty big delta when compared to the best watercooling gear available (8-10c under load).

You can improve the performance of the unit by "modding" it to add a 120mm fan (voids warranty of course):

remove the stock 92mm fan
build a 92mm shroud from another 92mm fan by removing the fan motor assembly (scalpel plz nurse!)
attach 92mm-to-120mm (included) mount converter to shroud
screw 120mm fan to 92mm-to-120mm mount converter
attach 120mm fan to case

In my experience this improved the temperatures under load by 1-4 degrees, depending on your tolerance of fan noise. You need the shroud because a 120mm fan is bigger then the heatsink for the pelts.

Coincidentally, I just removed the Freezone in lieu of a watercooling setup that I'm in the process of building. Thermochill 120.3, Storm, DDC+ with Petra Top. Once everything is up and running I'll try and post my findings.

Last edited by vinylkid; 01-08-2007 at 02:59 PM..
  #7  
Old 01-08-2007, 03:44 PM
newls1 2[H]4U, 6.4 Years
 
newls1 is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by vinylkid View Post
I've been running a Freezone for the better part of 9 months now. While it does a great job of keeping temperatures down at stock voltages (and relatively modest overclocks ... say, an Opteron 170 @ 1.55v, or a E6400 @ 1.55v), the unit can get noisy when you start pushing your overclocks. The heat dissipation capabilities of the pelts and their heatsink really become apparent on high overclocks. Also, after 9 months of operation I do notice that a wee bit of air has gotten into the loop, without a reservoir or fillport you can't do anything about this.



The typical temperature delta on my C2D E6400 @ 1.55v is 34c idle, 62c load on the highest cooling setting (ambient room temperature is around 22c). That's a pretty big delta when compared to the best watercooling gear available (8-10c under load).

You can improve the performance of the unit by "modding" it to add a 120mm fan (voids warranty of course):

remove the stock 92mm fan
build a 92mm shroud from another 92mm fan by removing the fan motor assembly (scalpel plz nurse!)
attach 92mm-to-120mm (included) mount converter to shroud
screw 120mm fan to 92mm-to-120mm mount converter
attach 120mm fan to case

In my experience this improved the temperatures under load by 1-4 degrees, depending on your tolerance of fan noise. You need the shroud because a 120mm fan is bigger then the heatsink for the pelts.

Coincidentally, I just removed the Freezone in lieu of a watercooling setup that I'm in the process of building. Thermochill 120.3, Storm, DDC+ with Petra Top. Once everything is up and running I'll try and post my findings.
Thats the answer i've been looking for. Thanks brotha, you just saved me a $300 mistake.
__________________
<<<<<NO PC>>>>>
2002 Tahoe / 7000watts going to 4 18" HDC3's / DC Power Dual 300Amp ALTS / 3 DEKA Intimidator G31 batts / MLA 15.4v module / 100+FT of 0/1ot power/ground cables / 25CUFT box @ 36Hz 442SQIN port/ etc...... LOUD!
  #8  
Old 01-08-2007, 04:33 PM
Thawaxshop Bad Trader, 3.2 Years
 
Thawaxshop is offline
Freezone is old, its been upgraded to the "eliminator"

http://www.3dgameman.com/content/view/6163/103/
  #9  
Old 01-08-2007, 04:42 PM
vinylkid n00bie, 3.5 Years
 
vinylkid is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by vinylkid View Post
I've been running a Freezone for the better part of 9 months now. While it does a great job of keeping temperatures down at stock voltages (and relatively modest overclocks ... say, an Opteron 170 @ 1.55v, or a E6400 @ 1.55v), the unit can get noisy when you start pushing your overclocks. The heat dissipation capabilities of the pelts and their heatsink really become apparent on high overclocks.
Just a clarification here: the pump itself is pretty quiet (no matter what the load is like), the 92mm fan included with the unit doesn't really cut it when you start overclocking heavy since the heatsink is saturated with heat from the peltiers. You need to use a significantly more powerful fan and a bigger heatsink to dissispate the heat dump from the pelts... I used a Panaflo 120mm (tried both Ultra and High models) connected to a rheobus controller. But even at the highest fan speeds (meaning loud fans with heaps of airflow) the temperature delta was more then +20c's.
  #10  
Old 01-08-2007, 05:03 PM
CaptRingold Limp Gawd, 5.0 Years
 
CaptRingold is offline
As someone said above, I dont see how it could be too hard to snip in to this at some point and add on a gpu block to the loop..

.. but then again, I've always bought kits before for exactly this reason: I've never seriously 'modded' anything, and dont want to bother starting.. But this doesn't seem any harder than modifying, say, an already assembled watercooling kit a new part.

I've already got a spare 12cm panaflow, not sure how much this rheobus controller of which you speak would cost.

What about the rest of the job though? Maybe a seperate resevoir to allow refilling?
__________________
14 AMD Ghz for [H]
  #11  
Old 01-08-2007, 05:21 PM
Rock&Roll [H]ard|Gawd, 9.3 Years
 
Rock&Roll is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thawaxshop View Post
Freezone is old, its been upgraded to the "eliminator"

http://www.3dgameman.com/content/view/6163/103/
Check out the Cool IT web site. The Eliminator is the baby brother to the Freezone, not a replacement, and is available for half the price.
__________________
System: Core I7 920 @ 4200MHz 1.45vCORE 1.35VTT 1.2vIOH // EVGA x58 Classified E760 // 6GB Dominator GT 1866 @ 1688 6-7-6-18 1T 1.65V
Cooling: Heatkiller 3.0 LT CPU block // 655 Pump // GTX360 Radiator with 3x Scythe slipstream 3000RPM on shroud
GPU: 8800GTS 640MB (648/1024)
Monitor: Sony GDM-FW900
  #12  
Old 01-08-2007, 05:22 PM
Dunno Limp Gawd, 6.4 Years
 
Dunno is offline
I wonder what would happen if you put one of these things between a std rad and the waterblock?:


The rad should bring temps down to 'ambiant' while this drops them sub ambiant!
Should make a nice room cooler at idle!

Wonder how they do it though; attempts to use ice caps to cool water have generally been unsucessfull with DIY rigs. Must slow the water down a lot through the blocks? Multipass Perhaps?
  #13  
Old 01-08-2007, 05:46 PM
vinylkid n00bie, 3.5 Years
 
vinylkid is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by CaptRingold View Post
As someone said above, I dont see how it could be too hard to snip in to this at some point and add on a gpu block to the loop..
I think adding a GPU block to this would be pointless. Most GPU's run much hotter then CPU's and given my experience with the unit, the added heat dump into the coolant fluid from an additional GPU would saturate the heatsink/pelts even faster.

You'd be better off building a full blown watercooling loop if you ask me.

Quote:
I've already got a spare 12cm panaflow, not sure how much this rheobus controller of which you speak would cost.
A Sunbeam rheobus is cheap, maybe $15 -- it's a fan controller. Or you can volt-mod the fan down to 7V operation with a resistor. (Zalman makes one, Noctua includes one with their fans too)
  #14  
Old 01-08-2007, 06:10 PM
CaptRingold Limp Gawd, 5.0 Years
 
CaptRingold is offline
Hmm, thanks.

Appears that much-cheaper (Nautilus 500) watercooling loops with a proven ability to soak up the heat from hotter cpu's and gpu's would be a better bet.

Or, alternatively, something like a Koolance pc3 720 case that I think [H] reviewed

But this is definitely something appealing for someone interested in only a processor I suppose. Apparently not worth the trouble to mod though.
__________________
14 AMD Ghz for [H]
  #15  
Old 01-08-2007, 06:41 PM
BlueCreek n00bie, 3.1 Years
 
BlueCreek is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rock&Roll View Post
Check out the Cool IT web site. The Eliminator is the baby brother to the Freezone, not a replacement, and is available for half the price.
It's actually both. It is the "baby" brother (they are actually almost the same size,) however it is quite new and includes several improvements over the original Freezone including easier installation and a sturdier mounting for cases with a 120mm fan. The main difference is that the Eliminator has half the pelts. Their sales claims it has 80% efficiency/results of the Freezone, however I read one review that tested both and noticed only a couple degrees difference under load.

As people have posted, this system can do an excellent job, but to do so requires the fan at higher RPM, which can be loud. Again, this is all just based on a number of reviews I've read.

The post I find most interesting is by vinylkid who actually has owned one of these for awhile. Regardless of how great it performs for reviewers, nine months is not a great timeframe to start showing reduced performance in my opinion, and it's just such a new product very few people have tested it for longevity, which brings us to possibly the biggest draw back of all-in-one sealed systems like this. When they break, you pretty much have to replace the whole thing unless you are a confident modder.
  #16  
Old 01-08-2007, 07:25 PM
forcefed Gawd, 5.6 Years
 
forcefed is offline
Non upgradable? Whats stopping someone from attaching a splitter in the line and running it to their own gpu block? Nothing really.
Can we get some c2d temps next time?
__________________
Sig goes here...
  #17  
Old 01-08-2007, 07:31 PM
Manny Calavera 2[H]4U, 5.7 Years
 
Manny Calavera is offline
I want one that could handle a 8800 oc'd as well as an oc'd C2D cpu for under 400.
__________________
Core i5-750 @ Stock | 2x2Gb Crucial PC3 1600 Ballistix @ 8-8-8-24 | XFX HD5870 @ 875/1200 | MSI P55-GD80 | Nec 2470WNX-BK | LG 1751S | Vista Home Premium X64 + XP Pro x32 |Modded Lian Li PC65b II+|1x Patriot Torqx 128Gb | Samsung F1 753LJ 750Gb x4 || WD 320Gb AAKS || Samsung 183S+Samsung 203S| Corsair HX750| FuNC 1030.r | G11+MX518 | SB Audigy 2 ZS |AKG K601 + Beyerdynamic DT250-80's | ATH-ESW9 | RSA Predator -
  #18  
Old 01-08-2007, 08:01 PM
sickpuppy Limp Gawd, 8.6 Years
 
sickpuppy is offline
Bottom line is I am really tempted to get this, but I would like to wait to see if a 2nd edition would come out with expandability.

For 300$ I an on-par custom kit would be able to handle 1-2 graphics cards too. Agree?
__________________
Workstation: Conroe 2.4@3.15, 2gb Corsair@1120mhz, Gigabyte DQ6, BFG 8800GTS 640mb, Audigy 2 Platinum Pro ZS, Klipsch Promedia 5.1 Ultra, Lian Li V2000, Westinghouse 37"ws , Viewsonic 21"ws
Media Center: A64 3200+, 1GB RAM, ASUS K8V, Geforce 6800 OC
File/Apache/PHP/SQL Server: P4 3.0, 1GB ECC, Supermicro P4SCI, 3Ware 8500, 8x250GB SATA RAID5, 80GB RAID1, PCP&C 510W
  #19  
Old 01-08-2007, 08:26 PM
BlueCreek n00bie, 3.1 Years
 
BlueCreek is offline
Actually, from what I've read here and there in other discussions, there is definately a limit as to how much peltier systems can handle. They sort of each have a threshhold and if you get above a certain point, the system not just under-performs, but completely bombs out (this is not first hand experience, just what I've read.) But what that point is for this specific system, I don't know. However, since it isn't expandable and comes only with a CPU block, I'd be very hesitant to experiment with how well it can handle a GPU (let alone 2 in SLI) added two the loop when it's not designed for it in the first place.

The third revision is supposed to come out in Q2 and will built to handle the Kentsfield line, which might mean that system would be more capable of splicing a GPU cooler into the system.

Last edited by BlueCreek; 01-08-2007 at 11:01 PM..
  #20  
Old 01-08-2007, 09:52 PM
Anemone Limp Gawd, 5.9 Years
 
Anemone is offline
If your going to mod it, might also consider reversing the airflow so you can give it fresh outside air. All the testers are listing "ambient" temps when they test the freezone, but it's sucking out case air, meaning case temps. Give that thing 120mm flow and cool fresh air and things get more interesting.

If you visit the Coolit site there is mention of the upgrade, something called Boreas, which gives 12 pelts, 2 cpu blocks and a gpu block. That's in addition to a dual 120mm fan push/pull config and I'd bet their is some serious cooling power. That's something I want for my own
Reply


Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:14 PM.


Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional

Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 2000 - 2009 KB Networks, Inc.