Hi all, I beg you for some advice.
Before now I still used old LG 915FT+ CRT screen. I was happy with it, but unfortunately it died on me, and so I been forced to look for new screen. Because I didnt want to save money on something that will spend so much time looking at, I decided to buy something better than average LCD NEC PA241W.
Unfortunately I have discovered the white-glowing black of the IPS technology EXTREMLY distracting. (The NEC had also serious problems with colours, but I have discovered that this can be fixed by calibration with SpectraView II and Spyder 3. sRGB emulation is working very well now btw. (Luckily I have been able to borrow the stuff for calibration - not that I owned it)).
So, as I can return the screen in 14 days here, I have decided to try buying Eizo S2433W to get rid of the ips glow. The Eizo with its PVA indeed improved the blacks and the glow is gone - the dark scenes in films are MUCH better. I also love its EyeCare mode which allows me to use extremely low brightness (I am used to set brightness very low when I write in Word in the night.). There are unfortunately some bad things too though. The PVA colour shifting is not as bad as the IPS glow so lets say I would accept that. Worse problem is, that S2433W doesnt have proper sRGB emulation. Playing with color adjustment in Eizo screen manager improved things, but I am still considering if it is enough (I am not sure if you can use Spyder 3 to improve colours for non colour-managed apps on this monitor. Never used other software related to calibration than SpectraView II.). And one thing that is totally unacceptable is the video tearing that I am experiencing. I always thought that video tearing is more related to the videocard and drivers, but I have both LCDs connected to the same card at the same time in duplicate mode and only the Eizo has tearing (this test shows it very clearly on it http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRe9ykSfXyQ&NR=1).
So now I am sitting here with PA241W and S2433W connected at the same time and deciding which one to return, or if I should return both and look for yet another one.
I am going to use the display like this: 50% MS Office & web browsing (I must be able to set very low brightness to prevent eye fatigue), 25% watching videos (Would love to have good blacks without IPS glow for the dark scenes. And no tearing!), 15% photo editing (Just a hobby - I dont need professional results, though I was hoping for somewhat better colours than the cheapest LCDS.), 10% games (Top response times not necessary, but it should still be enough for occasional gaming.).
I dont really need wide gamut. If the display is going to be wide gamut, it should have working sRGB emulation.
I want 16:10 screen, preferably 24 1920x1200, though I could also consider smaller display with only 1680 x 1050. My budget is 1000EUR, but I am willing to spend that much only if I will be really satisfied. I am thinking if I maybe should not buy something much cheaper now and wait for some new technology (OLED, where are you?) to appear.
Please advise, as I really dont know what to do now.
Before now I still used old LG 915FT+ CRT screen. I was happy with it, but unfortunately it died on me, and so I been forced to look for new screen. Because I didnt want to save money on something that will spend so much time looking at, I decided to buy something better than average LCD NEC PA241W.
Unfortunately I have discovered the white-glowing black of the IPS technology EXTREMLY distracting. (The NEC had also serious problems with colours, but I have discovered that this can be fixed by calibration with SpectraView II and Spyder 3. sRGB emulation is working very well now btw. (Luckily I have been able to borrow the stuff for calibration - not that I owned it)).
So, as I can return the screen in 14 days here, I have decided to try buying Eizo S2433W to get rid of the ips glow. The Eizo with its PVA indeed improved the blacks and the glow is gone - the dark scenes in films are MUCH better. I also love its EyeCare mode which allows me to use extremely low brightness (I am used to set brightness very low when I write in Word in the night.). There are unfortunately some bad things too though. The PVA colour shifting is not as bad as the IPS glow so lets say I would accept that. Worse problem is, that S2433W doesnt have proper sRGB emulation. Playing with color adjustment in Eizo screen manager improved things, but I am still considering if it is enough (I am not sure if you can use Spyder 3 to improve colours for non colour-managed apps on this monitor. Never used other software related to calibration than SpectraView II.). And one thing that is totally unacceptable is the video tearing that I am experiencing. I always thought that video tearing is more related to the videocard and drivers, but I have both LCDs connected to the same card at the same time in duplicate mode and only the Eizo has tearing (this test shows it very clearly on it http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRe9ykSfXyQ&NR=1).
So now I am sitting here with PA241W and S2433W connected at the same time and deciding which one to return, or if I should return both and look for yet another one.
I am going to use the display like this: 50% MS Office & web browsing (I must be able to set very low brightness to prevent eye fatigue), 25% watching videos (Would love to have good blacks without IPS glow for the dark scenes. And no tearing!), 15% photo editing (Just a hobby - I dont need professional results, though I was hoping for somewhat better colours than the cheapest LCDS.), 10% games (Top response times not necessary, but it should still be enough for occasional gaming.).
I dont really need wide gamut. If the display is going to be wide gamut, it should have working sRGB emulation.
I want 16:10 screen, preferably 24 1920x1200, though I could also consider smaller display with only 1680 x 1050. My budget is 1000EUR, but I am willing to spend that much only if I will be really satisfied. I am thinking if I maybe should not buy something much cheaper now and wait for some new technology (OLED, where are you?) to appear.
Please advise, as I really dont know what to do now.